Sam Raimi wasn’t the initial choice to direct Doctor Strange 2. The first film’s director, Scott Derrickson, another horror movie stalwart, was supposed to be at the helm again to do the follow-up. However, due to creative differences (if you ask Kevin Feige) and the need for a mental health break (as per Derrickson), the Sinister director vacated his role and remained on the board as an executive producer only. This meant Sam Raimi only had two years between 2020 and the film’s release in 2022 to put his own stamp on the film while making sure that Kevin Feige greenlit the entire thing. Make no mistake, there’s nothing wrong with Raimi’s efforts, but over the past few months, we’re starting to find out what Derrickson originally had planned for the sequel. Someone on Reddit went ahead and compiled all of the legitimate information they could about the potential plot for Derrickson’s Doctor Strange follow-up, and it could’ve made for a very different film. Basically, the gist is that Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness would be a Cosmic Horror film presumably inspired by HP Lovecraft’s Mountain of Madness. More importantly, instead of featuring The Scarlet Witch as the main villain, Derrickson’s original plans were to bring in Nightmare and delve much deeper into Stranger’s psyche. We’ve since gotten confirmation of some of the details rounded up by the said user and the several concept arts for the film that have popped up over the past few days confirm what could’ve been a drastically different take on one of last year’s biggest hits. The gloomier version of Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness has gotten plenty of praise online. Some fans even go as far as to exclaim that audiences got robbed by what was supposedly a “better” version of the film. It’s unclear how the plot of Doctor Strange 2 would’ve gone if Derrickson didn’t leave, but the images show Wong, Mordo, and Wanda Maximoff helping Strange make sense of what’s happening to the multiverse. Ultimately, this is all water under the bridge. Derrickson’s Doctor Strange 2 is a potentially good film and it could even better than Raimi’s version. At this point, it’s just a shame that we can only imagine what the film would’ve looked like if Derrickson stayed on. Nightmare is an actual Doctor Strange villain that would’ve made for a more compelling storyline than a corrupted Wanda. While we’re glad Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness was interesting enough to pull Raimi out of his hiatus and return to directing superhero flicks after Spider-Man 3, we can’t help but wonder about what could’ve been. Hopefully, we’ll get a proper compromise for Doctor Strange 3 and see both Raimi as well as Derrickson work together to mesh their ideas for a proper Lovecraftian horror entry for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. Doctor Strange 3 isn’t expected to premiere anytime soon. Most likely, it will be a part of Phase 7 of the Marvel Cinematic Universe after The Multiverse Saga ends with the delayed premiere of Avengers: Secret Wars on May 1, 2026. The last we heard, Secret Wars will take a page out of Endgame’s book but feature the multiverse instead of time travel.
